Expunged Criminal Records: Do They Really Go Away Forever?
New Jersey law permits those arrested or convicted of certain crimes to petition the court for an expungement under certain circumstances. When expunged, the records are isolated and removed from the files of any agencies that have them. Anyone who requests that person's criminal record is told that no such record exists.
But what if a person outside official channels knows about an expunged criminal record and releases it to the public? The New Jersey State Supreme Court is considering just such a case in an effort to determine whether exposing someone else's expunged record is grounds for a defamation lawsuit.
The New Jersey Law Journal reported today that the state's top court will consider the issue. (Subscription required). In G.D. v. Bernard Kenny and The Hudson County Democratic Organization, Inc., a political operative for a State Senate candidate became the target of flyers produced by a political rival. The flyers referred to the operative's prior drug conviction, which was previously expunged.
Regardless of how the Supreme Court rules on this case, expungement remains an important way to protect a person's record and prevent a past mistake from haunting him or her in the future. Expunged records can be used by the courts only in limited circumstances. For example, a judge may review expunged records when sentencing a defendant in connection with a subsequent conviction. Parole boards may also view expunged records.
Otherwise, state law provides that when a record is expunged, the arrest, conviction, or any other proceedings connected with the crime "shall be deemed not to have occurred, and the petitioner may answer any questions accordingly..." (N.J.S.A. 2C52-27). Consequently, petitioning for an expungement can be helpful to those who fear a background check may turn up damaging information.